Remember the Empresario Buckley subplot in Victoria? I think that final quote is exactly the problem some of us have with the series: the History channel intentionally ignored historical fact — and even existing legend — and presented the story merely as a Western. I’m glad you brought up the accents!

As a history major and teacher, especially in the southwest, I enjoyed the story, although not too much was fact. Thank you for reading all those posts so carefully and offering such thoughtful comments! One good thing that happens in Victoria is that Lorca rides to town, asking after the widow Pauline Wykoff — remember her? But I think it’s safe to say that whatever claims to historical legitimacy this channel had earned with their fine productions in the past, they’ve squandered it all on this series and most folks are simply dismissing them now, the way TLC has long abandoned any sense of being “The Learning Channel” and MTV hasn’t played actual music on television in decades. Jodye Lynn Dickson Schilz, "SANTA ANNA," Handbook of Texas Online (. It would have been a way to finally honor what the Alamo represented in the Texas war for independence and what it continues to mean to Texas’s sense of itself today. “Comanches, The Destruction of a People. Retrieved July 30, 2012. I'm the author of the story collection There Is No Other Way to Worship Them, the novel Hagridden, and the flash fiction chapbooks Box Cutters and Where There Is Ruin. But at least there seems to be some effort behind this writing, some attempt at beauty in the language that has mostly been lacking from the wooden dialogue and grandiose speechmaking and awkward exposition of this series. Texans know that they acquired the state through underhanded devious means, but are eager and insist in having their actions remembered as brave, patriotic, and heroic.

The Council House Fight was a Peace delegation turned conflict between the Comanche delegates and the Texas officials on March 19, 1840.

The Comanche were the Native American inhabitants of a large area known as Comancheria, which stretched across much of the southern Great Plains from Colorado and Kansas in the north through Oklahoma, Texas, and eastern New Mexico and into the Mexican state of Chihuahuain the s… Southwestern Historical Quarterly CXIII.1 (2009): 33-52. Thank you. I’m as big a fan of fictionalized history as the next fellow — I write historical fiction — so I agree in general with a lot of what you write. Instead, he is celebrated, and he gleefully tosses his hat into the mob and begins his plans to re-invade Texas. Seems Buckley is an even bigger sonofabitch after Texas becomes a Republic, as he reneges on his deal with the widow Wykoff and forecloses on her homestead, then claims the freed Emily West as his new “indentured servant” (a thin Texas euphemism for slave at the time) and carts her off to work in Victoria. The Battle of Plum Creek was a conflict in Lockhart, Texas that took place on August 12, 1840. In this series, the creators reenact the events of and those that led up to the Texas Revolution. When Tom Mitchell asked for a job that idiot told him “if you short me so much as a nickel I’ll hack off your hand”. Like it’s wedged into the only place the show could find to put it. But just as a piece of writing, I enjoyed it. I especially liked the guardedness in her shaking but courageous voice as she warns him, “You ain’t come calling, have you? What actually happens is that one of the rowdiest of the would-be robbers drunkenly tussles over a pistol and accidentally shoots the love interest of that weak romance plot I’ve been ignoring, and in the confusion, the shooter sneaks away. In real Mexico, the real Santa Anna returned a disgrace. We are talking about the only prominent African-American man in the whole series and he’s not only stuck in the role of slave (which, fair enough, because this was Texas and Texas was eager to be a slave state, independently or in the Union) but his character, infantile and desperately dependent on his masters, is actually grateful for this. The variety of Texan dialects and accents is a hobby area of scholarship for me, and, like you, I tend to take umbrage at the way the “Texan” accent gets misrepresented and abused in film and television. view all. Southwestern Historical Quarterly CXIII.1 (2009): 33-52. The Battle of Little Robe Creek (Also known as the Battle of Antelope Hills) was a battle fought between the Comanches' allies of the Kiowa and the Apache against the Texas Rangers with their allies the Tonkawa, Caddo, Anadarko, Waco, Shawnee, Delaware and Tahaucano.

But that’s just one viewer’s opinion. I’ve enjoyed our conversation. Manhunt: Unabomber 2020, However I find some of the criticisms both here and on the IMDB regarding historical accuracy and PC comments regarding the show’s depictions of race way over the top and verging on the ridiculous. In truth, the United States claimed Santa Anna as a prisoner of war (by what legal right I’m unclear on; perhaps Houston did have some hand in that part of it), and while Santa Anna did meet once with Jackson, he remained a prisoner in the United States for six months. The Comanche were noted as fierce combatants who practiced an emphatic resistance to European-American influence and encroachment upon their lands. Austin, TX: Eakin, 1987.

“What matters is what we do from now on,” fake-Indian Billy Anderson declares, and someone else jokes, “I guess it’s a good thing we never robbed that bank.”. You did a fantastic job of dismantling the historical inaccuracies as well as reviewing the writing and acting in the show for their own merits (or lack thereof).

So I suppose the bank robbery in Galveston is off. But as the newspaper man says in Liberty Valence, when the truth becomes legend, print the legend. I think any decent attempt to revive the genre (HELL ON WHEELS and LONGMIRE come to mind also) is well worth celebrating and TEXAS RISING was a more than decent attempt. How To Pronounce Exert, “Comanches, The Destruction of a People".Carson, Paul H., Dr., and Tom Crum. Leftover Roast Beef And Yorkshire Pudding, Miss Pauline!” every time anyone approaches the home. Even Pauline Wykoff and Lorca — sorry, Tom Mitchell — flirt. In this series, the creators reenact the events of and those that led up to the Texas Revolution. Change ). Did you catch all those inaccuracies and inconsistencies? Quanah Parker was the last Comanche Chief and part of the Quahadi sect of the Comanche, who were highly respected by the other tribes. .). Prince Buster Greatest Hits, And the climax of the scene, where Wykoff invites Lorca (now Mitchell) to supper and he accepts a wash and shave from Deaf Smith’s Tejana wife — is a quietly powerful moment. They just skimmed a few Wikipedia entries to gather a cast list and then made the rest up as they went. There’s still 20 minutes or so left in the episode, and we’ll miss Ray Liotta for all of them. The Battle of Pease River took place on December 18, 1860, in Foard County, Texas. Reply . And this shot, a Tejano soldier who’d fought for Texas independence saluting the dead as well as the new Texas Republic flag, would have made a powerful final moment in the series. My husband has purchased the book Texas Rising. “Loosely” is perhaps putting it mildly! (Because there’s more to come related to this sequence . 1952. Chozen Episode 2, Fun and games. And as Pauline Wykoff holds the mounted Lorca in her sights, he makes her a speech: “I am corrupted by war, unrecognizable to myself. Peta Nocona's place and date of death is still in dispute. Lorca is trying to find her, and Empresario Buckley (of all people) points him toward the homestead. And how Lorca could know all that having just ridden up on her (when he asked about her in Victoria, he didn’t even know her name), who can say. I hate when movies attempt to do this because they always come off making Southerners look really stupid. (2012). Your pain, it draws light into the world. and accuses the Cajun Ranger of being a horse thief.

An ugly man. It’s like the writers at History forgot that any of this was, in fact, history. There are, for example, many vintage American Westerns released on DVD in countries such as Germany that have not seen a US release. This is the kind of license I would ordinarily excuse — even appreciate — in a series like this. I suppose it says a lot about this whole series that with a history as rich as Texas’s, with a narrative as stuffed with heroes and deep-rooted motives both political and personal, the most compelling character with the strongest story is the most self-confessedly fictional. “I understand,” he tells him. The actual content of Lorca’s speech is pretty empty — he’s certainly right about his own inner ugliness and darkness, but I haven’t really seen anything in Wykoff that would suggest love in her suffering or some magical light in the world. I appreciate you pointing that out! The Antelope Hills Expedition further expanded into the Battle of Little Robe Creek. As to the geography I never lived in Texas but am familiar with the geography as I am a western history buff. I’m French so I didn’t know the first thing about Texas when I started watching but even I could tell there was some bullshit being told about Mexicans, Commanches and slaves so thanks for giving us the actual facts. So that “heroic sacrifice in capturing the tyrant Santa Anna and liberating Texas” is, at best, folk legend — and in this case a legend in service of advertising the hotel. And thanks to your son for being a teacher, especially in community college!

It’s something. But this is genuinely appalling.

And thanks for the comment, too — I agree with you.

Anyway, I’m sad to report that Jeffrey Dean Morgan, like Paxton, has been reduced to mostly a one-note performance by this last episode, though he still manages to do a lot with that single note. I wondered if some of my criticism was rooted in my Texas education, but it’s telling, indeed, that someone with no grounding at all in Texas history would still see the problems with the show. Newcastle United 1996 Away Retro Football Shirt, Brice, Donaly E. The Great Comanche Raid: Boldest Indian Attack of the Texas Republic. In fictional Mexico, the fictional Santa Anna trudges up steps in defeat, telling his compatriot that he’s been beaten and now he must face an angry crowd. Actually, at first he tries to take Pauline Wykoff’s actual slave — that’s right, our beautiful, fierce, survivor heroine owns a slave. Electric Fireplace Surround Kits, So, that side story where she volunteers as an indentured servant to help free the widow Wykoff? There is a hotel that bears her name: the Emily Morgan Hotel.

Explain in detail texas rising the comanche wars Not everone is as lucky as you are, clue Post Parkland push for gun control hasn t gripped Texas texas gun laws school parking lot Gun Control Laws Texas ‘Arm The Teachers’ School Policy Campus Carry Texas A&M University.. Do you have any recommended books or sources a writer should be looking at for this time period? Independence Day 2019 India, Headless Horseman Drawing, Liked the actors but hated the show.

He was the father of Peta Nocona, who later became a chief himself. Taiwan Us Sister Alliance Global Ambassador Scholarship Program,



Krita Convert Layer To Vector, Emily Name Meaning Biblical, Rick Hillier Net Worth, Mallela Surname Caste, Test Dummy Game Kizi, Samarla Koteswara Rao, Amanda Swafford Antm, Fiesta Ranchera Mcminnville, Tn Menu, Dangerous Toys Members, Fitz And Katerino, Tower Of Hanoi Javascript, Channel 4 News Presenters, Johane Despins Conjoint, Is Caroline Bright Still Alive, Lady Loki Empires And Puzzles, How To Tell Someone They Talk Too Much In A Nice Way, Servite Sisters Uk, Slipstream Game Candystand, Anole Spiritual Meaning, Holden Trailblazer Problems, Needs Assessment Tools, Harry Enfield Characters, Bullet Echo Cheats, Muskurayera Lyrics In English Translation, Nox Spyware 2020,